Get in Touch


->Contact us

Examining Crime and Public Safety: Outcry Over Fatal NYPD Shooting of Mentally Ill Queens Teen Holding Scissors

Examining Crime and Public Safety: Outcry Over Fatal NYPD Shooting of Mentally Ill Queens Teen Holding Scissors

Examining the Tragic Fatal Shooting of Win Rozario by NYPD: Questions on Mental Health Response and Police Tactics

The fatal shooting of Win Rozario by an NYPD officer has ignited widespread outrage as new details emerge, shedding light on the troubling tactics employed by the officers in response to a 911 call made by Rozario himself. This tragic incident has not only raised concerns about police conduct but has also sparked broader questions about the city's approach to mental health emergencies.

Ruth Lowenkron of New York Lawyers for the Public Interest describes Rozario's death as a stark example of a systemic failure, highlighting the distressing reality of a young man seeking help only to meet a tragic end at the hands of law enforcement. His death marks the 20th killing of a mentally ill person by police in the city since 2015, underscoring the urgency of addressing the flaws in the current system.

The sequence of events leading to Rozario's death unfolded rapidly, with officers responding to multiple 911 calls from Rozario and his family in the past. Despite prior encounters with law enforcement, the situation escalated quickly, culminating in Rozario wielding scissors and ultimately being shot by the officers.

The lack of body-cam footage and transparency regarding officer identities and disciplinary history has fueled skepticism and calls for accountability. Civil rights attorney Joel Berger questions the official narrative, suggesting that the incident "doesn't add up" and emphasizing the need for a thorough investigation into police conduct.

As the investigation continues, the tragedy of Win Rozario's death serves as a poignant reminder of the urgent need for reform in how mental health crises are handled, and the imperative of holding law enforcement accountable for their actions in such sensitive situations.

Reevaluating Police Responses to Mental Health Emergencies: Advocating for Alternative Solutions

Civil rights attorney Joel Berger criticizes the use of lethal force in response to Win Rozario's mental health crisis, emphasizing that officers should have utilized de-escalation tactics instead of resorting to deadly measures over a pair of household scissors. Berger advocates for mental health crises to be addressed by professionals trained in de-escalation techniques, with police intervention being the last resort.

Councilwoman Lynn Schulman echoes this sentiment, lamenting the tragic outcome of Rozario's call for help and emphasizing the need for mental health professionals to respond to such emergencies rather than law enforcement. She highlights the Behavioral Health Emergency Assistance Response Division (B-HEARD) as a potential solution, which dispatches teams of medical professionals and social workers to handle mental health crises.

Ruth Lowenkron underscores the importance of programs like B-HEARD in deescalating potentially dangerous situations, but voices concern over the limited reach of such initiatives due to budget constraints and lack of expansion plans. Despite Mayor Adams' pledge to expand B-HEARD citywide, budget cuts have hindered its implementation in areas like Ozone Park, where Rozario's tragic shooting occurred.

Jordyn Rosenthal, director of advocacy at Community Access, emphasizes the need for comprehensive mental health services beyond crisis response, including respite centers and clubhouses. She asserts that addressing mental health emergencies requires more than just temporary fixes and calls for sustained investment in supportive services.

As advocates push for alternative approaches to mental health crises, the tragic death of Win Rozario serves as a sobering reminder of the urgent need for reform in how such situations are handled, with a focus on de-escalation, community support, and long-term solutions.

In conclusion, the tragic shooting of Win Rozario by NYPD officers amidst a mental health crisis has sparked calls for reevaluating police responses to such emergencies. Advocates, including civil rights attorney Joel Berger and Councilwoman Lynn Schulman, emphasize the need for mental health professionals to lead interventions, with law enforcement as a last resort. The limited reach of programs like B-HEARD underscores the challenges in implementing alternative solutions, highlighting the importance of sustained investment in comprehensive mental health services. As the conversation continues, the death of Win Rozario serves as a poignant reminder of the urgent need for reform to ensure that individuals in mental health crises receive the support and care they deserve, without facing the risk of deadly force.